I gave a presentation the other day to a bunch of lawyers and legal professionals. It was supposed to be about AI. And all the wonderful things it could do. It morphed into something else and I hope confirmed an important lesson. Something I learned years ago in Boy Scouts: be prepared. And expect the worst. 

My Plan

I thought I had a pretty good plan. I was going to use a PowerPoint, along with some live demonstrations, to show what AI could do. The plan was to weave back and forth between the PowerPoint and the live demonstration to keep the presentation interesting. But as I was about to find out, the boxer Mike Tyson was right: Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth. 

All I needed was an external monitor so everyone could see what I was doing, a way to connect my laptop to the monitor and, of course, a reliable Wi-Fi connection. Simple, right?

The Facility

I practiced law for a long time. I’ve been in and out of a lot of courtrooms. One thing I learned was it’s always a good idea to visit the courtroom in advance. To look at the layout. To figure out where you will stand. Where the jury will be. Where the screens will be. And whether the technology you need is in place and works.

So on the Friday before the Monday presentation, I journeyed to the facility to check things out. And that’s when the first signs of trouble appeared. The facility folks knew nothing about the presentation. For a moment, I wondered if I had the wrong date or location. I checked my saved emails. Nope, I had the right time and place. And after some scurrying around, the facility figured it out: the person responsible for special events had apparently never put it on the calendar. OK, things happen.

That mystery solved, I went to the room where the presentation was to take place. It was a large room and had a gigantic monitor in the front. So the first issue, that of having an adequate monitor, was taken care of.

Then the second issue: connecting my MacBook to the monitor. There was no accessible HDMI hookup, so I had to connect wirelessly. I tried connecting. Nothing but a blank screen. I wondered if the monitor just didn’t like MacBooks. After a few frantic calls, a tech person appeared, and together we managed to figure it out and connected my MacBook to the monitor. Sigh of relief.

On to the next issue: could I connect to the Wi-Fi? Easy peasy. Worked like a charm. But then an issue I hadn’t foreseen cropped up. Every time I tried to switch back to the PowerPoint, the Wi-Fi network kicked me off. Crap. 

More huddling with the tech person. Finally, after switching to several other Wi-Fi networks, trying several SSIDs, and taking several sequential steps, we found a workaround. The tech person smiled. I felt better. 

She said, “And don’t worry, I’ll write down for you all the steps we went through along with the Wi-Fi password that you will need to access the network that worked. I’ll leave the notes on the podium for you.” Great. 

I headed for the door, but then it hit me. What if she forgot to write it down? So back I went. I confirmed all the instructions, typed them into my iPhone, and got the Wi-Fi password. Now I’m all set, right? Wrong. I forgot one thing. Her telephone number in case I needed her on Monday.

But what the heck, I had all I needed. I slept well that night. Over the next couple of days, I practiced my presentation from home, switching back and forth seamlessly between the PowerPoint and ChatGPT through Wi-Fi. And, by happenstance, I rehearsed using Claude.

The Morning of the Presentation

The morning of the presentation. I’m driving to the facility when it hits me. What if I can’t give the live demonstration? What if the Wi-Fi doesn’t work and I can’t access the Internet? 

I park my car, and after thinking for a moment, I run all the prompts I was going to use through ChatGPT. I then have ChatGPT make some backup PowerPoint slides with the outputs just in case. I also cut and paste the prompts and responses into a Word document I can use if all else fails. The whole thing took about ten minutes thanks to Chat, by the way. Now I have a backup and a backup to the backup. 

By coincidence, about that time, I get a call from the organizer of the presentation, wanting to make sure everything was good to go. I chuckled with her about deciding to create extra screens as a backup. She asked me if she should make paper copies of the PowerPoint for the attendees. I almost said, “Oh no, that won’t be necessary.” But something told me better get paper, so I said OK.

The Presentation

Now we’re at the facility. The tech person’s instructions are nowhere to be found. But what the hell, I had typed all information into my iPhone.

I’m the second presenter. The first presenter is going on about some topics that I know little about. I’m busy fine-tuning my presentation when I notice a silence in the room. I look up, and the presenter’s PowerPoint is frozen on the monitor. Must be an operator error, I assume, and go back to prepping. Should’ve paid more attention.

Now it’s my turn. During a break, I connect my laptop to the monitor, just like we talked about. Then I connect to the Wi-Fi network. I do a test run and voilà, it all works! I’m good to go. Or so I thought.

I’m on my own

I start my presentation with a personal story about my grandkids and some photos that are in my PowerPoint. Everybody smiles. I make a joke about powerless and pointless PowerPoints. And how I hate creating them. How AI helped me do it. I pull up the first substantive screen and start talking about it. Then I advance to the next screen. Nothing. I try again. Again nothing. 

I try to go back to the previous screen. Still nothing. Silence in the room. All eyes on me, wondering what the hell this guy is gonna do now. I look up at the monitor. Now it’s completely black. Nothing. This is going from bad to worse. And I don’t have the tech person’s number, so I’m on my own.

Then the monitor disconnects from my laptop completely. Must’ve been a glitch, I figure. I make a joke about technology, and how every time there is a technological presentation, there are tech problems. Everyone laughs. I reconnect. PowerPoint immediately freezes again.

The good news is everyone, including me, has paper copies of the PowerPoint presentation. And the Wi-Fi is working flawlessly. So I think: I can create some of the PowerPoint screens on the spot with prompts. That would show that, in addition to everything I’d planned, GenAI can also do PowerPoints.

It’s going to be a great lesson, right? Wrong: ChatGPT won’t respond to a prompt. It won’t create a PowerPoint slide. It has a strange message the likes of which I have never seen, saying in red letters it was blocked from responding. I try again. Same message. Ugh.

Again, silence in the room, again everyone wondering now what. I’m thinking I’m going to have to use the Word backup and read the responses. But wait, there is an alternative. I switch to Claude, and, whew, just like that, it works. (I asked ChatGPT afterward why it did that, and it didn’t have a clue btw. So, I guess it could have just as easily been Claude that froze.)

Lessons Learned

So at the end of the day, by being nimble, I was able to demonstrate how you can use AI to do a variety of things. I also showed how it helped me create a backup for the prompt answers, and how having a paper copy of the PowerPoint can be helpful. 

But I think I also taught them a larger lesson as I explained what I had to go through to create redundant backup systems. It came from something I learned long ago on the eve of trial. This was back in the day when we used slides projected on a screen to show pictures to a jury.

As I was getting ready, an older partner happened to ask me if I had a backup plan. In my youthful know-it-all exuberance, I said, “I don’t need one. I’ve got the slides, and I’ve got the projector.” He said, “What if the projector fails?” I rolled my eyes but got physical copies of the pictures just to humor him. Of course, when I got to the courtroom, the projector wouldn’t work. 

Technology is wonderful. Until it isn’t.

That taught me an important lesson: technology is wonderful. Until it isn’t. I remembered that when I told the organizer, yes, better make copies of the PowerPoint. I’ve learned to always have a backup or two or three. Had I not gone to the facility in advance, written down the instructions the tech person gave me, practiced and rehearsed, used both ChatGPT and Claude, created backup slides and the Word document, or agreed to the paper copies, the presentation would have been far different. 

The lesson: while you can’t anticipate every problem, you can anticipate that there will be problems. That’s true of any presentation. Of any hearing. Of any trial.

Case in point: even as I was writing this piece, Microsoft, the platform on which just about every lawyer in America depends, had a massive 36-hour global outage. It hit just about everything and everyone, including lawyers and courts. Another reminder to not depend solely on technology or one platform. To have backup plans, to prepare for the what ifs.

Alls well that ends well

So Alls well that ends well. I was able to complete the presentation. I can’t say it went off without a glitch, but I can say I did what I intended. I was able to make adjustments, keep moving, and not take the punches too seriously.

And at the end of the day, the best technology in the room wasn’t PowerPoint, ChatGPT, or Claude. It was the preparation and judgment to know what to do when they failed. It was anticipating Tyson’s punch in the mouth. And being ready to take it. 

I was intrigued when I recently read about Reveal’s Onna platform that can now collect what employees put into and get out of Claude Enterprise. Come to find out, Onna already had done the same for ChatGPT and Gemini, and other e-discovery providers offer similar tools. These tools make it easier when it comes time for responding to discovery requests. It’s also a good reminder that employees may think what they tell Claude is private. It isn’t.

Training and education are key. Here’s my recent discussion of all this for Above the Law.


I’m always interested in Clio’s Legal Trends Report that comes out at its vendor’s conference. Clio has lots of data from its customers and otherwise and the Report is always informative. 

What stood out this year was counterintuitively, billable hours are up not down in the age of AI. I had been thinking that hours should be going down. So I may have been wrong.

I got to talk to always perceptive and articulate Lenon of Clio at the conference about the reasons for what seems to be a paradox. And those reasons suggest to me that the trend may not be long-term. Here are my thoughts for Above the Law.

There’s a lot of talk these days about what AI can do. Draft briefs. Review documents. Analyze contracts. Conduct research. Brainstorm ideas. Solve problems. And I’d be the first to say, AI can do a lot. But there’s something AI can’t give you. A mindset.

The determination to find a way to solve your client’s problem, no matter how difficult it looks. The instinct to start with yes instead of no and then figure it out. The willingness to keep looking when the obvious answer doesn’t work. And the understanding that what clients really want isn’t a recitation of all the reasons something can’t be done.

That Damn Bin

I was on a flight recently. You know the drill. We all pile on, stuff our bags in the overhead and hope there aren’t any delays. Then the flight attendants come through and close all the overheads with a bang. Except this time, they didn’t. Or couldn’t.

Continue Reading The Overhead That Wouldn’t Close: A Lesson in Problem Solving

I attended two keynotes at two different vendor conferences recently. The first was at the NetDocuments conference and was presented by CEO Josh Baxter and his team. Here is my write-up for Above the Law. The second was at the Clio conference and was done by its CEO, Jack Newton. Here is the write-up again for Above the Law.

Not only was there a wide divergence in style between the two, they presented a stark difference in strategy and approach.  NetDocuments is focusing on integrations and partnerships. Clio on unifying all products under one roof.  It will be interesting to see whether and which one wins out. 

I attended a fascinating presentation while at NetDocuments Inspire conference. It asked the question of the impact of AI on the relationship between in-house lawyers and outside counsel. The issue whether these two groups will work together on AI adoption and use. Or whether they will go their own ways, which could proof disastrous for outside counsel. I talk about what I think will happen in this piece for Above the Law. What do you think?

I’ve always wondered about all those surveys that suggest how much lawyers are using AI. Especially when I ask how many in my presentation audiences are using AI and few many hands go up.

A Visier study makes me question AI use even more. 48% of those surveyed say they exaggerate AI use. It’s worth thinking about. Here is my post for Above the Law.

One thing I learned over the years about litigating: front end loading and early case assessment were critical for success and strategy. The problem was that took time and clients often balked at paying for it. So when I saw that the recent AI Guide for Litigators from the Thomson Reuters Institute and ILTA focused on just this kind of assessment among other phases, I was intrigued.

Here is my discussion for Above the Law of the Guide and how AI can make early case assessment faster and cheaper.